Ready for the fat tail of climate risk to wag?


· 6 min read
What commenced as an American phenomenon is now witnessing Europe entering a spiral of its own. With insurers withdrawing coverage, households and businesses are losing protection, and the costs are increasingly falling on public budgets.
A recent Finance Watch report sets out how Europe can preserve natural hazard insurance – a key trigger for uninsurability – as an essential service, with affordable coverage backed by public-private risk-sharing at national and EU levels.
“Public support must be tied to concrete prevention, climate adaptation, and decarbonisation action. Better dealing with losses from extreme weather events will not be enough without reducing the risks driving them.
“Market forces will not resolve this crisis alone. The upcoming EU climate resilience framework must match the scale of the challenge,” says Paul Fox, Senior Research and Advocacy Officer.
Richard Noren, transformation strategist, illustrates its brutality: “Europe has an €822 billion monster hiding in its balance sheet. That’s how much weather and climate-related extremes cost the EU between 1980 and 2024, according to the European Environment Agency. The home for some of the top insurers and reinsurers in the world.
“Only around 20% of those losses were privately insured. And the last four years in the dataset were among the five costliest since 1980. This isn’t just a climate debate. It’s about infrastructure, supply chains, insurance, financial resilience and how companies manage risk. We need to stop treating resilience as an optional expense and start treating it as a strategic investment. Because the real monster isn’t the next storm. It’s discovering that nobody budgeted for what comes after.”
‘Confronting the Insurability Crisis’ – a new framework for natural hazard insurance by Finance Watch – argues that Europe is moving from a longstanding insurance protection gap into a full-fledged insurability crisis as climate change intensifies floods, storms, wildfires, and other natural hazards.
Historically, around three-quarters of disaster losses in Europe have been uninsured, believes Fox. As risks rise, insurers are likely to increase premiums, narrow coverage, or withdraw from high-risk regions. While these actions may be rational for individual firms, the report contends that they shift risk onto households, businesses, banks, and governments, creating broader financial instability.
The report’s central argument is that natural-hazard insurance should be treated as a public good and guaranteed through public-private partnerships. It proposes designating natural-hazard insurance as a Service of General Economic Interest under EU law, ensuring affordable coverage for all citizens, and requiring insurer participation in national insurance schemes.
The report views uninsurability not as a market problem alone but as a systemic economic risk requiring coordinated action by insurers, governments, regulators, and society to maintain affordable coverage while reducing underlying climate risks. However, it does not stop here. Some market reports indicate devious trends.
Mary Sweeters – Insure Our Future Global Network Coordinator – shares this story: Inside Track x (Re) Insurance is a group of senior professionals in the UK & European insurance and reinsurance industries. “Everyone in the group holds – or until recently has held – senior roles in the industry’s leading non-life insurers, reinsurers and broking firms,” she writes.
Very recently, senior European and UK (re)insurance professionals published an anonymous memo warning that industry models show climate risk growing “at a dangerous rate” and critiquing the sector’s strategy of exiting high-risk areas. The memo garnered headlines in mainstream and insurance trade press and prompted a firestorm of conversation among science, investment, and policy professionals.
The authors highlight a “collective cultural denial” about the consequences of the industry’s strategy and note that risk levels are not properly internalised by governments and investors.
An anonymous whistleblower working for a major insurer in catastrophe-risk modelling – assessing the risk posed by natural disasters on properties around the world – has to say:
“In the face of ever more extreme and unpredictable climate risks, I am coming under pressure to cut my forecasts for the losses that disasters will cause in order to make insurance more affordable – and get my employer more business. In some instances, the questioning of our numbers and models is justified. But too often, it is not being done to produce more accurate models, but to artificially lower prices. If this is happening at my firm, which is struggling to compete with rivals’ prices, it’s happening elsewhere.”
A version of this piece originally appeared with The Bureau of Investigative Journalism (TBIJ) as part of their Secret Source series, a regular column featuring industry whistleblowers.
Despite the warming global climate causing more frequent high-intensity storms, rising sea levels, flooding, wildfires, and drought – insurers are carrying more risks than we realise. While the immediate impact of these events is plain to see, the long-term effects will be compounded as insurers withdraw from affected areas, leaving the economy in freefall and people’s day-to-day lives in ruins.
Under pressure to reduce projected losses, we are collectively fudging the numbers and taking on more risk than we should for a lower price than the expected loss demands. This will eventually lead to a sector built on “competitively priced” contracts that underestimate risk, leaving gaping holes in the safety net that insurance is supposed to provide.
There is a problem with the attitude of much of the industry towards modellers, actuaries, and researchers: there is a sense that we are an inconvenience to the deal-making process, rather than an essential part of risk management. We are the failsafe that stops our industry from reckless gambling.
Customers are likely to be much more exposed to climate-related risks than they realise. People are not budgeting for a major increase in their insurance premiums or planning for their homes becoming uninsurable, but many of them absolutely should be.
If the worst happens, the insurance industry may not have the money to pay every claim when a major disaster hits. That would have profound consequences for the economy as a whole – businesses could go bankrupt, the housing market could seize up and, if people couldn’t pay their mortgages, banks would fail.
As insurers try to navigate profound uncertainty while coping with climate risks – they attempt balancing commercial pressures, regulatory expectations, customer affordability, and capital requirements. Let us hope the whistle blower alerts only represent exceptions and not the rule.
HIH Insurance (Australia) spent years writing insurance too cheaply, underestimated future claims, pursued risky acquisitions, and failed to maintain effective governance. Once the hidden losses surfaced, the company became insolvent. Independent Insurance (UK) also collapsed in 2001 because it understated its liabilities, carried inadequate reserves, and obscured the true scale of claims losses.
The implosions came from within their respective balance sheets. While tinkering with forces of nature let us not forget that “the economy is a wholly owned subsidiary of the ecosystem” (Herman Daly). This time around if risk levels are not properly internalised, and externalities not priced – the ramifications are systemic. The fat tail of climate risk could wag not just the insurance industry but could turn much of the global financial order uninsurable. All eyes on Europe!
illuminem Voices is a democratic space presenting the opinions of leading Sustainability Thought Leaders, their views do not necessarily represent those of illuminem.
The world needs sustainability knowledge. At illuminem, no interest group or shareholder can influence our work. Thank you for supporting our mission to make high-quality and independent sustainability information free for all. Every contribution helps. Thank you for donating today.
Praveen Gupta

Insurance · Climate Change
Steven W. Pearce

Cities · Insurance
Diego Balverde

Public Governance · Insurance
The Insurer

Insurance · Sustainable Finance
Financial Times

Insurance · Sustainable Finance
Forbes

Sustainable Finance · Insurance